Maud Earl (British, 1864-1943)
PROPERTY OF A CANADIAN COLLECTOR
Maud Earl (British, 1864-1943)

'What We Have We'll Hold', a portrait of Dimboola the Champion Bull Dog

Details
Maud Earl (British, 1864-1943)
'What We Have We'll Hold', a portrait of Dimboola the Champion Bull Dog
signed and dated 'Maud Earl/'96' (lower right)
oil on unlined canvas
30¼ x 40 1/8 in. (76.8 x 101.8 cm.)
Painted in 1896.
Literature
The New York Times, 9 July 1943 (obituary).
The Herald Tribune, 9 July 1943 (obituary).
Britain's Bull Dogs Past and Present Safeguards of the Nation, n.d., illustrated on cover.
Engraved
Photogravure, 1900, published by Henry Graves & Co. Ltd.

Lot Essay

Perhaps more than any other artist born in the 19th Century, Maud Earl was the pre-eminent painter of pure-bred dogs. W. Secord considered that, 'when it came to painting the purebred dog, Emms was far surpassed by his contemporary, Maud Earl, and there can be little doubt that she stands out among the many 19th Century artists who painted dogs.' (A Breed Apart, Woodbridge, 2001).

She was born into an artistic family, the only daughter by the artist George Earl's first wife, Alice Beaumont Rawlins. Her uncle, Thomas Earl, was also a talented painter of horses and other animals. Maud was taught by her father and at the Royal Female School of Art, where she quickly developed her natural talent for capturing the true character of her canine subjects. Her half-brother, Percy, was also an artist who completed many commissions of horses and purebred dogs.

She exhibited regularly in England and Europe, and was a prolific and much sought after artist who painted many of the important dogs of the day, including those belonging to the Royal Family and important dog fanciers. She attributed much of her talent to her natural affinity for her subject, 'You can't paint dogs unless you understand them; I don't mean merely from the fancier's point of view. You must know whether they are happy and comfortable, and if not, why not. You must know how to quiet them when they become excited and nervous. You must know all their little likes and dislikes, and this knowledge comes from long experience.' (The Young Woman, November, 1898).

Her works were immensely popular with the public for whom images of the dog were an important reflection of their affection for the animal. Purebred dogs in late 19th Century England were extraordinarily popular as new breeds were imported and established, and Maud Earl further reinforced their importance by completing their portraits in oils. In 1897 she had an exhibition in which she showed paintings of forty-eight varieties.

By 1916, she had received international recognition with several solo exhibitions, and her work was widely reproduced both in books and print form. Her work may be loosely divided into four styles, the naturalistic, richly painted portraits of dogs from 1880 to 1900; a highly finished but looser, more sketchy style from 1900 to 1915; what she referred to as her oriental style from about 1916 to the 1920s after she emigrated to the United States, and her late rather stylized portraits of dogs during the 1930s in America. It was during her early years in America when she painted her little-known but elegant paintings of birds, which she considered some of her best work.

The Bulldog is rivalled only by the Mastiff as a contender for England's national breed, and is also one of England's oldest and most beloved dogs. It was bred originally as a guard dog and to bait bulls and bears, although this aspect of their pre-19th Century history would rather be forgotten by most modern enthusiasts for the breed. The first mention of a Bulldog with its modern spelling was in 1832 but the history of the breed is much older, having been originally developed during the reign of King John (1199-1216) when bull baiting was thought to have been started in England. Around 1800 there was a great reaction against the sport and it was considered immensely cruel. In 1835 bull and bear baiting was prohibited by law and as a result dog fighting also declined. From that point on Bulldogs became champions of the show ring as the era of the modern dog show began. As Edgar Farman comments, 'For the show bench as an object lesson of what can be done by scientific breeding for 'points', the Bulldog is an excellent example of the triumph of man over nature'. By the 1890s when the present picture was painted, the Bulldog had been a longstanding member of the dog show world. What once had been a strong and tenacious fighter had now become, though selective breeding, a show dog and pet but it was still embodied with the ideology of strength and fortitude and hence was an apt symbol at the time for the power of the British Empire.

The present work was clearly intended to be a patriotic display of Britain's strength and naval capacity with the Champion Bulldog of that year, the British flag and the ships in the background seen off the white cliffs of Dover. The print issued in 1900 after this work was widely disseminated and became a popular image in England during the early 20th Century. As a sign of how compelling the image became, it was used on the front of a promotional pamphlet after World War I that was published in Canada and which listed several English political and military figures of the time.

Dimboola Champion, owned and bred by Mr J S Pybus-Sellon, was whelped on 13th April 1893 and was white with lemon markings. His sire was Stockwell and his dam Dextrine.

More from Sporting Art

View All
View All